I am very serious about this.  Just because we see things differently on a lot of things doesn't me we don't see eye to eye on anything.  Hell, Ken and I agree on college football!!

by ProfRich on 05/15/2008 06:52:46 PM EST

[ Parent ]
Do you think that this bias is entirely unfounded, or that there are kernels (small and or large depending on the specific claim) of truth there?


by Tom Hanc on 05/15/2008 08:21:18 PM EST

[ Parent ]

Step 1) Take everything I said about Southerners and translate it into black people. 

Step 2) Now take all the stereotypes we have thrown around about southerners and translate them into thier black counterpart

Step 3) Ask your question about black people 

How many times have you heard some white guy say, "I know its a stereotype but its true about black people (being criminals/not having jobs/having babies out of wedlock/liking fried chicken/having various grotesque physical features)?  Did you feel those people were making a compelling argument?

Look, the point is are some Southerners idiots?  Do some love Nascar and drink too much beer and have a poor understanding of America, its governmental system and ideals?  Do some wear wifebeaters and have mullets and beat their wives?  Sure.  Does John Edwards? Does he deserve to be painted with that brush?  That is how bigotry works.   

by ProfRich on 05/15/2008 10:44:46 PM EST

[ Parent ]
But pragmatically speaking, it's damn near impossible to treat each and every person on earth as an individual 100% of the time.  There are over 6 billion reasons why it's not practical.

Ideally though, yes, that's what we'd always do.

by Tom Hanc on 05/16/2008 11:50:12 PM EST

[ Parent ]

And I don't think you are a bigot at all.  Just making a point.

I think there are bigotries we shine a white hot spotlight on and they whither and weaken (black) and some we acknowledge and they slip in the shadows but remain fairly strong (women, Mexicans) and those we completely ignore and those remain the same or even grow in power (Southerners in this case) 

by ProfRich on 05/17/2008 12:00:37 AM EST

[ Parent ]