LOGIN
Login
Create Account
TYT Membership
ARCHIVES
TYT Archives
Post Game
ABOUT
About
Press
Guests
Lexicon
FAQ
Facebook
Twitter
iPhone
Android
Promote
Fan Art
Huffington Post
Contact
PREMIUM
FORUM/CHAT
Create Account
Login
Discussion Forum
Chat Room
SHOP
Store
Library
Donate
Join
PODCAST
Podcast
HELP
Website Tips
Contact
FAQ
DONATE
Main Menu
Become a Member
Chat Room
Podcast
Cenk on Huffington Post
Questions
Viewing Tips
Website Tips
Library
Contact Us
Interviews
WTF?!
Join TYT
Press
About
Store
Guests
Donate
Glossary
Promote
Fan Art
Login
Log In
Create An Account
What's Kind of Civilian Killing is Worse?
|
54
comments (54 topical, 0 hidden)
depends on how you judge
(
none / 0
)
The line between civilian and military among Hamas is blurrier, because people who want to join Hamas probably come directly from civilian ranks without a whole lot of differentiation&nbs p;- they're a more populist movement by necessity, because if they were as separate from the civilian population as the Israeli military is, Israel would have gotten rid of them already. So in a way, civilian deaths are inevitable.
I voted that it's worse to kill 60 civilians, simply because in the long term, the more civilians die, the longer a population is likely to hold a grudge, and the harder it is for peace to take hold. I predict that after this military action, Israel will significantly reduce or even crush the group Hamas' grip on Gaza, but that new groups will form espousing Hamas' philosophy, and they'll be just as popular.
But on the other hand, Hamas' tactics were WAY less effective in terms of protecting their people than Israel's. They killed four civilians on purpose, they're getting their ass beat down. Israel kills 60 civilians and their international political clout is reduced. Both actions are bad decisions, but Hamas' were far more suicidal.
by
marlonm
on
01/04/2009 07:43:51 PM EST
What's Kind of Civilian Killing is Worse?
|
54
comments (54 topical, 0 hidden)
Home
|
TYTV Video Clips
|
Join The Young Turks
|
About the Show
|
Press
|
Store
|
Promote
|
Fan Art
|
Contact