Don Cheadle would make the perfect pirate, and Christian Bale has the rugged good looks (and the woman beatings) for the perfect All-American Navy Seal.  Matt Damon has the chops and the everyday genius look to be the FBI lead negotiator.  But we need to make the Captain more believable, he can't be some handsome charmer like Bruce Willis. 

We need a Capt who is a little unsightly, whose face shows they have been around the block a few times, someone whose looks tell a story of hardship but perserverance.  Someone who skirts the line between tough and dreadful.  An American with a world story, someone who you could picture throwing back shots in some seedy bar on the Kenyan coast.

May I suggest in his breakout roll, Captain Cenk Tiberius Uygur?