You can have a Black History Month and AT THE SAME TIME explain to students why you need a Black History Month and how in a perfect world (one which we seek to approach) we won't need a BHM, but that for now it serves a helpful function.  You can even recognize that BHM is a bad idea in theory, but understand that it serves a useful function in the present.

Next, I am annoyed at these elitists who only talk about affirmative action as a program to get black kids with lower grades into schools.  Elitists went to college, so they obsess on that.

Do the elitists (liberal or otherwise) realize that there is a world outside of their own direct experiences?  There are civil service jobs at various levels all over the country in which there is a legacy and a present of not hiring minorities. (I presume the New Haven, CT fire department is one such place.)  If these departments don't hire black people, then a circumstance or needs-based affirmative action program won't do any good.  The whole POINT is to implement a race-based affirmative action program to get minorities into these positions.

David

by yturks on 07/03/2009 01:40:20 PM EST

I absolutely agree that Black History Month served a valuable purpose, even though it was a flawed concept.  And I'm not saying that it doesn't serve a useful purpose today.  I'm just proposing that maybe it's time to move to a less racially focused celebration of that culture.  Maybe it's not yet time to do that, I don't know.  But someone has to make that proposal, and it might as well be me.

As for being an "elitist" and focusing on affirmative action in education rather than in all aspects of our lives, sure.  I will certainly give examples that are obvious to me, with which I have experience, and that are of value to me.  That doesn't mean, however, that I've ignored all of the other places that racial discrimination can occur.  It just means that I might not have the time to write about all of them.

by EveningStarNM on 07/03/2009 03:01:00 PM EST

[ Parent ]
...race-based affirmative action later.  But I'll probably just quote from the Constitution when we do.

by EveningStarNM on 07/03/2009 03:21:35 PM EST

[ Parent ]
Of course I'm kind of kidding when I threw out the elitism accusation, and in any case, I was referring more to Cenk than to EveningStarNM.

David

by yturks on 07/05/2009 03:58:53 AM EST

[ Parent ]
And here I was hoping that someone actually thought I might be elite in some way.

by EveningStarNM on 07/05/2009 07:17:06 AM EST

[ Parent ]