That is my ruling.
David
Yesterday after the show I briefly spoke to RJ and he said that even though he's in favor of passing the bill, Hamsher is 100% correct and that it makes a lot of great points.
So if her list is good enough for a healthcare consultant (who's also in favor of passing the bill), it's good enough for me. As for wanting more detail, that's what the links for all 18 points are for.