We worked the Democrats every day to get THIS piece of garbage done. Adam Green "pushed and pushed" and got a meaningless bunch of signatures from liars who will not support even a much-compromised Public Option, even with a need for only 50 votes.
The Democrats have a mandate and have leverage and have both Houses and the President and have completely tone-deaf opposition. And the Public Option would make good politics AND good policy AND satisfy their base and their Party platform. And would lower costs.
The next time, when Democrats have (probably) less votes in Congress, corporate money is even more an influence on the agenda, the problem is MORE expensive to fix, and the stupid American people and media are blaming "too much government" for this disaster, how much harder do you think we are going to push? The Democrats aren't listening to us, and our "pushing" has given Progressives basically no victories in this Health Care battle and 25 (and counting) losses to the Conservatives. We might as well be pushing a stone wall. This bill is not progress--it is a giant extortion scheme that we are mandated to fund, and lied to about by the people we elected to be leaders instead of pathetic doormats and co-conspirators. Unless we get some leaders, it doesn't matter how bad the problem gets, or how much we have accomplished thus far (i.e. virtually nothing), or how hard we "push"--there will be no meaningful Health Insurance Reform for at least another generation. Look at the trend--the Newt Gingrich Republican proposals for Health Care in the 90's were as strong or stronger than what the Democrats are proposing now. You think that the government is going to lurch to the Left because of the Liberals' astounding sales pitches?
Saying that the electorate isn't "that smart" is an understatement (as I am sure you know). As long as the narrative is ingrained into Independents that any tweaks to restore balance to the system are a "Marxist government takeover of America", then the people will be biased toward a Conservative mindset--EVEN IF THIS BILL PRODUCES SOME SUCCESSES. The conventional wisdom narrative doesn't care about what the actual truth is. "Obama is soft on terror", even though we killed more bad guys in 2009 than 2008, Obama increased the Defense budget, escalated the war, favors re-upping the Patriot Act, and will cave on every issue regarding detainees. "Tax cuts create more jobs", despite that Clinton's era created 18 million more jobs than Bush did. Stop thinking that the truth on the ground is going to shape our politics, when our leaders don't care what the public thinks, and the public is too lazy to research the truth anyway. It IS a two-party system, so when Republicans continue to completely wreck what is left of the country again in a few years, Democrats will be voted back into office. But why will they listen to us then? Why will they put their careers on the line to go back to this albatross?
You make a point that they need to eventually get "something" done so that the foundation is set. But the only lessons that will be taken from this are that if Democrats are desperate to pass the worst bill imaginable just to pass something, Republicans will negotiate EVERY bill down to the worst it can possibly be, because they know the Democrats can't say no. That is the peril when one side puts upon itself the inexplicable burden of "governing", and the other side's only job is to shut down the government, which is only a million times easier.
by
Milltycoon on
03/05/2010 09:13:08 PM EST
[
Parent ]