This whole discussion makes me think of the South Park episodes

Go God Go

Go God Go XII

So who of you knows the real interpretation of Dawkins' words, can you be an atheist without being mean and what should atheists call themselves.

"The first thing Fascists usually try to do is silencing the opposition."

by opposition on 03/09/2010 09:40:38 AM EST

Dawkins is often criticized for being mean, shrill, strident, etc... As someone who is very familiar with Dawkins I honestly can say these charges are unfair.

There is a taboo against challenging peoples religious beliefs and so when someone dares to do so there tends to be a knee-jerk overreaction. Really, there isn't anything he has to say regarding religion that is any meaner than what we are used to in our political and normal social discourse. It's a double standard.

In the preface to the paperback edition of The God Delusion Dawkins addresses this. In it he reads a random restaurant negative review from the newspaper that was way more shrill and strident than anything he says. Think of how much we are used to shrill and strident speech in our political discourse. I mean, you're a TYT fan, right? Society accepts such speech in stride. What Dawkins or anyone else has to say regarding religion should be no different.

by mr science on 03/09/2010 11:43:28 AM EST

[ Parent ]
I really don't consider him to be extraordinary mean, it was just a joke in this South Park episode.

People start to criticize the tone when they are not assured of their own believes. I'm very confident in my philosophical and religious believes and have no problem with anybody attacking it. In fact I would encourage that, because it helps me to fine tune my positions.
People who think that God would mind insults must be extremly petty.

"The first thing Fascists usually try to do is silencing the opposition."

by opposition on 03/09/2010 11:54:28 AM EST

[ Parent ]
Would, it's in the Bible. And that big guy LOVES to through some temper tantrums when he doesn't get good attention.

by Alloy on 03/09/2010 01:31:34 PM EST

[ Parent ]
(because I agree with it.)  I've observed the same thing about Dawkins.  He is incisive, and he won't accept vague answers and prevarication, but his manner isn't shrill or angry.  Now if you want a big mean atheist jerk, you've got Hitchens!

by borduin on 03/10/2010 11:01:25 AM EST

[ Parent ]