Self-Defeating?

Google Technorati del.icio.us digg reddit
 As a member of the Army JROTC program at my high school, I interact with many students who plan on joining the military, in one way or another. Some want to pursue ROTC in college, while others simply want to enlist out of high school. Debating with them on several topics can be interesting...

    It seems to me as if the future of our military may not be ready for the missions in Iraq and Afghanistan. What was once a mission to find and kill terrorists, now has become a mission to help rebuild a nation torn apart by civil war and an insurgency. It is the duty of the Soldiers and Marines in-country to help stabilize the region not only by providing security, but by helping the populace return to a normal way of life. That means rebuilding schools, hospitals, etc., as well as knocking on doors instead of kicking them down. For some of my fellow cadets, that seems a little too much.
     "I just want to kill 'Desert Monkeys'," said one of my classmates one day during a discussion on the war in Iraq. When I asked him whether or not he thought that wanting to kill the people you're trying to help is detrimental to the mission, he shrugged it off.
    &nb sp; "Marines just kill people."
    Well put, I guess. But my leatherneck compadre was only a light example of the problem. Even my more educated friends, one of whom is going to Norwich University next year, believes the mission is simply killing terrorists, and doesn't appreciate the gravity of what we are doing there. 
    &nb sp;  Is this a serious issue? To me, yes it is. If our military is going to win this fight, we need to have the best trained, equipped, and educated troops in the world. Perhaps, it's just a part of my generation. All I know is that If I end up patrolling the streets of Baghdad one day, I want my men to realize what they are truly doing, building a nation, rather than just "killing the bad guys."
< Ana, I have never heard such ignorant garbage... | The *Other* Way We're Screwing Iraq (That No One Talks About) >
 Display:
Stay sane, Westpointer. I would hate to see your fellows in a few years - the ones whose bloodlust and bigotry is so easily spewed when they are not in battle. Where are your seniors here?  I thought the ROTC was to teach leadership, not to sanction racism or barbarism.

by Verified1 on 03/03/2008 01:30:13 AM EST


They are right to a certain extent.  A big part of the problem is that we are trying to use the military for nation building.  What the military really excels at is taking things apart violently.  They should really only be used in that capacity, because I don't think military occupations ever work very well.  People just don't generally react well to armed foreigners in their country.

I do see your point and do agree that it is a problem, but maybe THE problem is nation-building with the military.

by bfaul on 03/03/2008 10:03:01 AM EST


I don't want someone that says things like " I just want to kill desert monkeys" access to a weapon under any circumstances.

by Chinese Democracy on 03/03/2008 02:32:09 PM EST


Stay sane, Westpointer. I would hate to see your fellows in a few years - the ones whose bloodlust and bigotry is so easily spewed when they are not in battle. Where are your seniors here?  I thought the ROTC was to teach leadership, not to sanction racism or barbarism.

by Verified1 on 03/03/2008 01:30:13 AM EST

No no no, they are not taught to think that way by JROTC, dont get that perception. It's just them, and the society and culture around them. Most of my friends are good people, who want to serve their nation proudly. However, they just don't seem to understand what they are really doing

by WestPointer on 03/03/2008 05:40:33 PM EST


 Display: