Economy speech contrasts today

What was the visual contrast of the candidate's two speeches today?

This morning, both candidates for President had speeches in regards to the economic crisis.

On the tone, which si what most low info Americans look at, I feel Obama won.

 McCain went first at about 9 am. As I watched I saw him throw barbs at Obama and speech in a very stilted, rehearsed tone. What message would any passing very get from this speech? Its your average stump speech that any candidate would give.

 

Obama came on sometime after 11 am, and his had a completely altered tone. He came out, flanked by economic advisors, and answered questions from the press in a very serious manner. He expounded on points and sounded very knowledgable. Then he said him and his advisors were going to get together and come out with a more specific, detailed plan in the coming days to deal with this. He also struck a very bipartisan, "we gotta pull together and get through this together" chord, as well.

 Why do I think this is better? Cause the contrast made Obama look very Presidential. Now, I love negative attacks and ripping up the other guy....but in a crisis like this you really need to look like you're ready to lead. Your average American would look at these back to back speeches today and see two things.....one, your average stump speech from a candidate for office....and two, Barack Obama holding a press conference looking like he already was President.

And after this Obama went uut and held a women-centric speech n Florida and ripped McCain to shreds, so that assured me that he couldlook both Presidential, but also like a fighter!

< McCain Blames Obama For Financial Crisis And... | John McCain is no war hero POW >

Poll

Did Obama win the speeches this morning?
Yes, he looked more Presidential 83%
No, I love John McCain and Phil Gramm 0%
You're a whiner, and the fundamentals of the economy are strong 16%
LOL WUT 0%

Votes: 6
Results | Other Polls
 Display:

Everyone here was getting nervous that Obama was backing off after a strong end of the week last week and a great Monday.

Hell, he was just busy.  Trying to make some sense out of the unprecedented events of the week.

Then, today, he gave a speech on the economy and a press conference that nailed it, as best as is possible while things are still unsettled.

Presidential?  He is ALREADY doing Bush's job for him as far as informing the American people.  Then again, Bush was never able to talk to the American people, unless he was trying to promote his neocon agenda.

Contrast with McCain?  There is none.  All McCain did today was a stump speech.

by rbruck on 09/19/2008 03:22:13 PM EST


Did you notice that in Obama's speech, he pretty much included as his second principle what I said in my rant this morning.  He even made the same Golden Parachute comment.

Here what Obama's said in his speech:

"First, we cannot only have a plan for Wall Street. We must also help Main Street as well. I’m glad that our government is moving so quickly in addressing the crisis that threatens some of our biggest banks and corporations. But a similar crisis has threatened families, workers and homeowners for months and months and Washington has done far too little to help. For too long, this administration has been willing to hit the fast-forward button in helping distressed Wall Street firms while pressing pause when it comes to saving jobs or keeping people in their homes. We already know that the credit crisis that has emerged from our largest financial institutions is becoming a credit crunch for small business owners, homeowners, and students seeking loans in big cities and small towns. Now that American taxpayers are being called on to share in this new burden, we must take equally swift and serious action to help lift the burdens they face every day. In the same bipartisan spirit that is being shown with regard to the crisis on Wall Street, I ask Sen. McCain, President Bush, Republicans and Democrats to join me in supporting an emergency economic plan for working families — a plan that would help folks cope with rising gas and food prices, spark job creation through repair of our schools and roads, help states and cities avoid painful budget cuts and tax increases, help homeowners stay in their homes, and provide retooling assistance for America’s auto industry. John McCain and I can continue to argue about our different economic agendas for next year, but we should come together now to work on what this country urgently needs this year."

"The second principle I would like to see in the emerging plan from the Treasury and the Fed is that our approach should be one of mutual responsibility and reciprocity. It must not be designed to reward particular companies or the irresponsible decisions of borrowers or lenders. It must not be designed to enhance the personal gain of CEOs and management. The recklessness of some of these executives has helped cause this mess, even as they walk away with multimillion dollar golden parachutes while taxpayers are left holding the bag. As taxpayers are asked to take extraordinary steps to protect our financial system, it is only appropriate that those who benefit be expected to contribute to the protection of American homeowners and the American economy. Just as support is not designed to payoff egregious executive compensation, it should not reward those who are ruthlessly foreclosing on American families.

"Third, this plan must be temporary and coupled with tough new oversight and regulations of our financial institutions, and there must be a clear process to wind down this plan and restore private sector assets into private sector hands after restoring stability to the system. Taxpayers must share in any upside benefit that such stability brings.

"Fourth, this plan should be part of a globally coordinated effort with our partners in the G-20. This is a worldwide issue, and while the United States can and will lead in stabilizing the credit markets, we should ask other nations, who share in this crisis, to be part of the solution as well."

And here is a link to my rant from a few hours earlier:

http://www.theyoungturks.co m/story/2008/9/19/11116/087 6


I wonder if he reads this forum...

by rbruck on 09/19/2008 04:10:17 PM EST

[ Parent ]

I wonder if someone at ObamaHQ doesn't read us.

I honestly suspect we are among the top five or ten progressive message boards around.

I asked other TYTers with a broader sense of these things where we rank, no one answered.

by ProfRich on 09/19/2008 05:13:03 PM EST

[ Parent ]

participation, though it seems like that's been picking up lately.  But judging by the other blogs I've looked at, the articles and comments on this site are much smarter and funnier (on average) than pretty much any other political board that I can find.

Group hug!

by Spencer on 09/19/2008 05:22:07 PM EST

[ Parent ]
Obama's comments were good, and thoughtful.  I wasn't able to hear McCain. Bush was terrible as usual.

David

by yturks on 09/19/2008 06:04:53 PM EST

 Display: