Palin's never issued an order to Alaska Guard

Google Technorati del.icio.us digg reddit
We have all heard the ridiculous claim that Sarah Palin has more experience than Barak Obama because she is the Commander and Chief of the Alaska National Guard. This is such a joke; I can’t believe people don’t bust out laughing when it’s said. The only things more inane being said is that she has foreign policy experience because Alaska is close to Russia (they don’t share a border, as some have said) and that she is a reformer.

Now it turns out Sarah Palin has never issued an order to the Alaska National Guard.

When John McCain introduced Sarah Palin as his running mate last Friday, he emphasized her role as the commander in chief of the Alaska National Guard as a reason why she was his choice. Then throughout the week as questions were raised about Palin's lack of experience in national and international affairs, the McCain campaign pointed again to her military command experience as governor.

Some reporters have even tried to follow up on this point. One such reporter was Campbell Brown on CNN, when she asked "Can you tell me one decision that she made as commander in chief of the Alaska National Guard?" This was a legitimate question by Campbell Brown, asked while interviewing McCain campaign spokesman Tucker Bounds. "Just one?" she followed up when he tried to argue she was denigrating Governor Palin. His answers were rediculous, and he looked stupid, and John McCain threw a tempertantrum afterwords. 

That Tucker Bounds couldn't give a real answer was because Sarah Palin has never personally ordered her state's National  Guard to do anything.

First Maj. Gen. Craig Campbell, the service commander of the Alaska National Guard has stated the governor has no command authority when their National Guard units are overseas or anywhere else in the United States other than their own state.

"When members of the National Guard are federalized, they work for the president," Campbell said Wednesday. "It's not just overseas. They could be federalized to go to other states or they could even be federalized in the state."

Are there occasions in which Palin would have retained command authority over the 4,200-member Alaska National Guard? Yes, she would have had authority whenever the Guard was asked to respond to an in-state natural disaster or civic emergency.

The trouble is (for Palin, not the state) is Alaska has had no reason to mobilize the National Guard.

"Natural disasters are fairly sporadic," said Jeremy Zidek, the public information officer for the state Division of Homeland Security and Emergency Management, which is part of Campbell's department. "Last year," during Palin's first year as governor, "there wasn't much action," Zidek said. “Thankfully, we didn't have any major disasters."

What are some examples of what the Alaska National Guard has done?

"We've deployed individuals in state service all over the state under Sarah Palin," he said. “We had defense men down in Seward for the (Mount) Marathon run doing security."

"Out west and northwest we had erosion problems, and the National Guard was involved in some of the protection out there. About three days ago, the Army National Guard picked up a lady from Little Diomede (Island)... at the request of state troopers."

Flooding also occurred in Fairbanks in late July — for which the Guard sent trucks north to provide clean drinking water.

Did Palin directly approve each of those activities?

"No." Campbell said.

It turned out that the governor has granted him the authority to act on his own in most cases, including life-or-death emergencies — when a quick response is required — and minor day-to-day operations.

The recent decision to deploy a C-17 cargo plane from the Alaska Air National Guard to Louisiana to assist during the Hurricane Gustav response was an occasion in which Campbell briefed the governor's office but Chief of Staff Mike Nizich was the person who signed off on it.

And Budget wise, the Alaska National Guard receives about 85 percent of its funding from the federal government, and all the federal funding is pre-allocated by Congress.

Wow, so much for her "experience&q uot; as Commader and Chief.

< Doesn't get any clearer than this | I make a motion we call her Spiro Palin >
 Display:
This is the way it probably works in most states but most governors aren't trying to justify a thin resume for a national level job and stretching it that this is commander in chief experience. This is grasping at straws and most people know it.  

by stanski on 09/04/2008 03:20:41 PM EST


they pretend that a state stops working without a governor or that a governor builds up a state from scratch

a governor gets the top spot, but the machine is already working before he or she gets put in place, now a good governor will make adjustments to make it run better, but nothing falls apart if the governor goes on holiday or if he/she falls sick for a long time

and as I said in the title, if lazy Bush could do, it can't be that much of a taxing job, especially when you consider Alaska has 1/35 of the population of Texas, that's not even a part time job

by callisto on 09/04/2008 04:43:14 PM EST


But it's sad that someone had to "fact check" this story.  The Pubs should be embarrassed for even THINKING they could sell someone as the potential (inevitable given McCain's age/health) POTUS by claiming they "commanded" the state National Guard.

What's next, serving on the PTA gives them executive experience or being in proximity to Russia gives them foreign policy experience?  Oh...  wait...

Seriously, they should be ashamed of themselves.

by Kang the Conqueror on 09/04/2008 05:13:58 PM EST


Isn't this where some troll jumps in and says we owe our very lives to her heroic sacrifice in facing down the threat of world domination from Canada?  And then asks what Olympics Obama ever held? Or tells us that Obama has less experience (chronologically) than guys who are really really old?

by NicoloM on 09/04/2008 09:25:42 PM EST


 Display: